Archive

Posts Tagged ‘chaos theory’

Interview: Jacob Marshall


Jacob Marshall

I have found that in just about every area of life “control” is a type of illusion built on chaos.
~Jacob Marshall

Jacob Marshall, passing through Pittsburgh on a farewell tour with his band Mae, graciously agreed to the following interview for The Renaissance Mob. In addition to being a skilled drummer and founder of Mae (Multimedia Aesthetic Experience), Jacob is a true polymath and social entrepreneur.

RM: Thank you for agreeing to this interview, Jacob. One point of interest for this blog is how one deals with the unpredictable nature of life. Some of the events which happened to you, leading up to the formation of your band Mae, were out of your control and impossible to predict. What insights can you share about coping with chaos in your life?

JM: Thanks for including me, I love what you are doing with this project and I’m honored to be a part of it. I got my first understanding of chaos on the ski slopes as a kid. It’s perhaps metaphorical to think of it in those terms but unless you surrender to the force and “chaos” of gravity you will never enjoy the freedom of riding. I have found that in just about every area of life “control” is a type of illusion built on chaos. In the grandest sense, our universe is built on the chaos of quantum mechanics and (potentially) m theory. In the most personal sense, our experience of the world arises out of the chaos where physical sensation meets mental perception. The mind’s ability to aggregate all of those vibrations into a perceived “reality” is truly remarkable. If you have had the pleasure of reading Oliver Sacks you know how delicate that experience of “normal” perception is.

“Every act of perception, is to some degree an act of creation, and every act of memory is to some degree an act of imagination.”
~Oliver Sacks, Musicophilia

RM: The name of your band stands for Multisensory Aesthetic Experience, and you’ve done some innovative things like spraying your CDs with scents and using multimedia in your concerts. What has been Mae’s goal or driving philosophy behind this multisensory appeal?

JM: In 1911, a Russian painter named Wassily Kandinsky wrote a book titled Concerning the Spiritual in Art

. He had an elegant way of describing different forms of art as different languages trying to tell the story of truth. He is often credited for inventing abstraction in art and used his experience with synesthesia as the basis for visualizing music in his paintings.

The idea for MAE came out of a two year research project I did back at Old Dominion University on the various relationships between color and sound. I believe that the emergent result of synergistic multisensory expression is just starting to be appreciated and art is evolving more and more in that direction.

Makoto Fujimura

RM: Your major at Old Dominion was an interdisciplinary study of aesthetics, which has played a large role in your work as a musician as well. Lately, you’ve made some connections with some notable figures in the art community, including painter Makoto Fujimura. Tell us how his philosophies have influenced your understanding of the arts and aesthetics.

JM: Mr Fujimura is one of my heroes and it has been an extreme pleasure to get to know him over the last two years. He uses the traditional Japanese nihonga materials in his painting but his form is a truly glorious take on abstraction and expressionism. There are always beautiful stories just below the surface of his work. We have really bonded over the artist’s struggle in the digital age and a mutual desire to plot a new course for sustainability. We have been exploring and building a model that marries financial capital, creative capital, and relational capital.

RM: You have a huge interest in the concept of emergence, which is directly related to Chaos Theory. You recently attended a lecture with Steven Johnson in NYC, who has written a whole book called Emergence. Any nuggets of wisdom you’d like to share from that event?

JM: That event was very special for me. We (mae) are in the middle of a two-month tour right now and we rarely get days off. We happened to have a night off in NYC on the exact night that two of my intellectual heroes were having a discussion about my favorite topic. Kevin Kelly and Steven Johnson both have new books out that respectively deal with emergence. Kelly’s book What Technology Wants

looks at the big picture of tech and makes interesting comparisons between the evolution of technology and nature. Johnson’s book Where Good Ideas Come From: The Natural History of Innovation

looks at the types of environments that foster breakthrough ideas. He shatters the illusion of the “eureka” moment and reveals the emergent nature of innovation. To top it all off, the host for the evening was Robert Krulwich of my favorite podcast/radio show, Radio Lab.

The main thing I took away from the evening was how the reality of innovation is much messier and than you might think. It’s much more like a flower slowly growing toward the sun than like systematic series of obvious steps. True breakthroughs are only ever obvious in hindsight. They require many mistakes. So when I am in the middle of any creative situation and feeling stuck, I will simply try to step back, see the bigger picture, and readjust my approach.

RM: Emergence has played a big part in Mae’s activities this past year. Can you tell us a little about how your “Make a Difference” project has employed the idea of emergence?

JM: After nine years of being singularly focused on mae, we knew that this was probably going to be our last chapter. We wanted to write an ending to this story that we could look back and be proud of. At it’s core, this “Make A Difference” campaign was forum for collaboration between mae and our listeners. We wanted to take the big picture of community development and break it down to the pixel level. In 2009, we recorded and released a new song every month exclusively through our website www.whatismae.com. Listeners from all over the world were able to download it directly from us for a donation. We committed all of the donated funds that came in to very specific humanitarian projects that we chose in tandem with our listeners. Over the course of the year we were able to fully fund and build a home for a family in VA with Habitat For Humanity. We also funded a variety of classroom needs with donorschoose.org and created a community service challenge for Destination Imagination called Project Outreach.

It’s so easy to look at the problems in the world and feel helpless. This project gave us and our listeners a chance to adjust our perspective and think of our individual actions as the pixel. Since a digital picture literally emerges out of the interaction between the pixels this served as a very appropriate metaphor. People took the vision and ran with it. We released one song per month and told a story over the course of the year musically. But the real story was being told by our listeners. Every time someone downloaded our music they were changing the pixels in a very specific picture. The solutions emerged out of the interactions between people as they were inspired to contribute humble pieces to a larger puzzle. We all worked together and the story that was written is something I will always be proud of.

RM: So Mae is disbanding, but, as you’ve said, the seeds from this project will continue to grow and take on a life of their own. You’re starting a new band now called “River James,” but what is next for you in your aesthetic and social entrepreneurship endeavors?

JM: The final mae shows will be in China and Japan in February. After that it’s all a bit up in the air. That is when chaos theory will completely take over my life :)
I am working on a new music project called River James and you can download our music for free at www.riverjamesmusic.com. I am also slowly working on a book called “Bear t.ia mart.” Thank you for the interview, it has been a pleasure!

100th Tweet ~ Indonesia, Wildebeest & Nostalgia


Tsunamis, like the one in 2004 (above) and the one this week, are examples of Black Swan Events.

A crucial link in Indonesia’s tsunami warning system was not working during Monday’s tsunami because it had been vandalised, says an Indonesian official.
~BBC News, October 27

Deciphering Twitter can be as nearly impossible as hearing one bird in a forest full of them. Every 100th tweet we’ll do a quick review of the ones worth special mention. If you are not doing so already, please follow us (@renaissancemob) for up-to-date news on RM topics, announcements of new blog posts as well as our new twitter book clubs. (We’re currently tweeting about David Freedman’s “Wrong

,” which can be found by entering “#dhfwrong” in the search window on Twitter.)

Black Swan Events
A Black Swan Event, as identified by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, is a highly improbable consequential event. In other words, it’s a random event you can’t predict. Its impact can be either positive or negative, so it’s subjective in nature. We’ll be keeping tabs (#blackswans) on Black Swans since they play such a large role in an otherwise mundane life.

27 October – BBC (Asia-Pacific) ‘No Alert’ in Indonesian Tsunami
Tsunamis, like weather patterns, are caused by a complex system of events. In this case it was triggered by an underwater earthquake. Because earthquakes and volcanos are impossible to predict, early warning systems were put in place two years ago in order for coastal residents to have advance warning of a coming tsunami. Here the Black Swan Event was as much the vandalism of the early warning system as the tsunami itself. The question is, did anyone know the warning system was not working before this happened?

Adaptivity/Emergence
It’s part of human nature to ask the question how did things come to be the way they are? …As well as what may develop in the future? Our tweets about adaptivity and emergence (#adaptemerge) provide links, quotes and info on attempts to answer that very question.

26 October – Blogcritics (Sci-Tech) Science, The Hadron Collider, and a Supreme Being
With the recent release of Stephen Hawking’s book “The Grand Design

,” many articles are out on how the complex system that is our universe might have come into being without a “need” for a Supreme Being. In this article, Regis Shilken claims that there is still the evolutionary problem/puzzle of human consciousness.

Chaos/Aesthetics
In a series of posts called “The Aesthetics of Chaos,” we are taking a look at how Chaos Theory gives us a natural guide for appreciating and understanding beauty, as well as why that’s important. To complement that series, we’ll be tweeting about chaos in art and nature (#chaesth).

26 October – Boston.com (A&E) Leaving (most of) it up to chance

13 October – The Huffington Post (Max Eternity) Buddha 2010: Contemporary Tibetan Art

Groupthink
One of the dangers our world faces is groupthink – on a scale never before possible. Where in ages past a madman could influence a crowd within the sound of his voice with powerful rhetoric, now organizations are global in their influence. We will keep watch on groupthink (#groupthink) – even where it is not recognized as such.

26 October – CNN (International) Corruption Survey: Somalia is the Worst

Swarm Intelligence

2010 Wildebeest Migration: an example of swarm intelligencePhoto Masai Mara

As we saw in Len Fisher’s book “The Perfect Swarm,” groupthink and swarm intelligence are two different things. With swarm intelligence, members of the swarm act as independent agents with a common purpose. Our tweets on swarm intelligence (#swarmintel) provide insightful articles and information of swarm activities.

25 October – CNET News (Technically Incorrect) Study: Bees are smarter than computers

16 October – Ifpress.com (Travel) Nature’s Thrill Ride, Wildebeest migration a sight to behold
.

.
Fractals
Fractal is a term coined by Franco-American mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot (who just died this month). A fractal is a geometric shape which is recursive no matter how much you magnify it. In his book “The Fractal Geometry of Nature,” Mandelbrot tied fractals to chaos theory. Tweets about fractals (#fractals) will have information on their relevance to life today.

25 October – Scientific American (Cross-Check) Benoit Mandelbrot (RIP) and a quest for the theory of really everything

Recurrence
One of the most profound lessons learned from fractals is the idea of recurrence – that there is repetition and at the same time variation at all levels of any system. There are some exciting things happening (#recurrence) in the study of recurrence.

22 October – SciTopics (Research Summaries) Recurrence Plot

Renaissance (Wo)Men
The Renaissance Mob promotes individuals becoming trained generalists. We believe that solving complex social problems requires independent, interdisciplinary thinkers. We tweet (#generalists) about such individuals and their contributions to society.

20 October – PTLeader.com (news) ‘Renaissance Man’ Bob Boardman Mourned

Complex Adaptive Systems
A Complex Adaptive System (#CAS) is closely related to a Chaotic System and Swarm Intelligence. It uses independently acting agents to produce solutions through emergence. Scientists, economists, psychologist and others are using it to understand human and computer networks and how processes evolve over time.

20 October – Wall Street Journal (Real Time Economics) Using Evolutionary Theory to Predict Economic Recovery

16 October – MSNBC (LiveScience) Deep Thoughts on What Makes Humans Special

07 October – NewsWise (The University of Alabama) NSF Grant to Art Professors for Emergent Learning Test

The Renaissance Mob (Youtube Favorites)
The Renaissance Mob has a brand new YouTube channel. Please subscribe! In addition to being a collection point for videos on RM topics, in the coming months we will be posting our own videos introducing our project and supplementing the blog.

19 October – The Mandelbrot Set (chalkboard video)

Chaos Theory
Most all RM topics are based on The Chaos Theory (#chth), especially as it applies to humans. Tweets on this topic are about understanding Chaos Theory and what we can learn from it.

13 October – SpringerLink (Journal of Statistical Physics) Chaos Theory Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow

Mandelbrot


Benoit Mandelbrot
20 Nov 1924 - 14 Oct 2010

I conceived and developed a new geometry of nature and implemented its use in a number of diverse fields. It describes many of the irregular and fragmented patterns around us, and leads to full-fledged theories, by identifying a family of shapes I call fractals.
~Benoit Mandelbrot, 1982

“A Greek among Romans” is what author and disciple Nicholas Taleb called him. A fitting label for someone who spent most of his life working on a mathematical philosophy no one else seemed interested in investigating. “Until a few years ago, the topics of my PhD were unfashionable,” claimed Mandelbrot, “but they are very popular today.” In fact, his specialty has blossomed into the field of Complexity Science, branching out with limitless application.

Mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot died earlier this month from pancreatic cancer. The extent to which this particular blog is indebted to his work and ideas is yet to be seen. That vast wealth resides in what Taleb would call the “antilibrary” – what we have yet to learn. However, this much is known: Mandelbrot’s work as a type of evangelist brought about an awareness to a transformative way of observing the world around us.

Over the past week and a half since Mandelbrot’s death, numerous articles about his life and work have populated the blogosphere. Listed below are some of the most informative ones. As for this post, it is only a prelude to some of the things we hope to find in the antilibrary concerning Mandelbrot.

Clouds are not spheres, mountains are not cones, coastlines are not circles, and bark is not smooth, nor does lightning travel in a straight line.

As part of our “The Aesthetics of Chaos” series, we’ll be taking a look at the various different forms of art and how the “fractal geometry of nature,” as Mandelbrot called it, gives us an aesthetic guide. One artist in particular, the Australian painter Robert Berry, will be sharing with us some of his insights on the topic of fractals, nature and aesthetics. Many of these ideas stem from what we have learned about fractals from Mandelbrot. While he was a mathematician, Mandelbrot did not see distinctions between fields of study as most of his peers did. One of the reasons he did not continue as a mathematician in France, he claimed, was because of their “rage against images.” Were it not for his openness to images, he would not have discovered the beautiful intricasies of what we now call The Mandelbrot Set. Insights gained from fractals fluidly link aesthetics to science. “Think of color, pitch, loudness, heaviness, and hotness,” wrote Mandelbrot. “Each is the topic of a branch of physics.”

My fate has been that what I undertook was fully understood only after the fact.

In the following 2008 PBS interview, Mandelbrot and Taleb warned about the increasing fragility of our complex world. When asked to make predictions about the future, Mandelbrot simply replied “anything is possible,” while warning about the importance of vigilance. In an up-coming book review, we will be taking a look at the new second edition of Taleb’s The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable. Many of Taleb’s ideas proceed directly from Mandelbrot’s work.

An extraordinary amount of arrogance is present in any claim of having been the first in inventing something,

One of the great insights stemming from his study of fractals was Mandelbrot’s view that recurrence is seen throughout nature. Even the above quote is a recurrence of Solomen’s lament “there is nothing new under the sun.” Part of our Chaos Journal project is to chart recurrence at the level of an individual. (If society is truly fractal in nature, then the smallest “pixel” of society is the individual.) At the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Dr. Norbert Marwan is a pioneer in studying recurrence in complex systems. Dr. Marwan has graciously agreed to allow The Renaissance Mob to use his CRP toolbox (http://www.pik-potsdam.de/) to study recurrence as a tool for understanding both self and society.

Thanks to Mandelbrot’s study of fractals, roughness and chaos, we continue to learn about aesthetics, addressing fragility, and understanding recurrence in life and society.

Other articles about Mandelbrot
Benoit Mandelbrot (RIP) and the quest for a theory of really everything By John Horgan Oct 18, 2010

Benoît Mandelbrot, Novel Mathematician, Dies at 85 By JASCHA HOFFMAN Published: October 16, 2010

Mathematician Benoît Mandelbrot dies aged 85 (Wikinews)

Mandelbrot, father of fractals, dies at 85 Sunday 17 October 2010

.

A Tale of Two Countries


2009 Worker Strike in Johannesburg, South AfricaPhoto ANP

It was the best of times,
it was the worst of times,
it was the age of wisdom,
it was the age of foolishness,
it was the epoch of belief,
it was the epoch of incredulity,
it was the season of Light,
it was the season of Darkness,
it was the spring of hope,
it was the winter of despair…

~Charles Dickens,
A Tale of Two Cities

There is chaos in South Africa. Crime has driven townspeople to take law enforcement into their own hands. Xenophobia still throbs beneath the surface, as desperate immigrants live in constant fear of an attack like the ones seen in 2008, where people were burned alive. And yet “there is a movement for Africa’s renewal,” writes Times Live columnist Nkululeko Ncana, and former South African president Thabo Mbeki might just be the man with the right ideas. In his October 17th article “Renaissance Man is Back” Ncana announces the launch of the Thabo Mbeki Foundation and Institute (TMALI) in Johannesburg last week. Mr. Mbeki, South Africa’s second post-apartheid president, was forced to resign two years ago after losing a power-struggle with his political rival, Jacob Zuma. During his presidency, Mbeki lead an unprecedented period of economic growth which created growing pains in the form of a greater demand and simultaneous lack of skilled labor as well as a growing gap between the rich and the poor.

Most Americans watching the recent feel-good movie “Invictus,” in which Morgan Freeman played Mbeki’s predecessor Nelson Mandela, might not be conscious of current events in South Africa. The movie centers around Mandela’s first term in office, highlighting his use of South Africa’s national rugby team to unify his country. The movie may end with warm feelings of the inherent goodness of man, but “it is not as though the continent is standing still” said Mbeki last week. In the past two years since Mbeki left office, South Africa has felt the impact of the crippling global recession with a surge in the cost of living. Add to this an influx of an estimated 1.5 million refugees from Zimbabwe, and you have a perfect recipe for civil strife. Last month, President Jacob Zuma announced the deportation of Zimbabwe refugees, but a September 2nd Voice of America article says this decision could be “tantamount to a death sentence” for the helpless and homeless Zimbabweans.

Another movie, out just months before Invictus, portrays the present-day xenophobia in South Africa in a rather unique way. Filmed as a pseudo-documentary, the sci-fi District 9 portrays a violent Johannesburg dealing with dumb aliens (called “prawns” for their shrimp-like appearance) which have been forced to take up residence in the city due to a breakdown of their spaceship. The movie follows the activities of one social-worker (played by real-life Johannesburg native Sharlto Copley) tasked with the eviction of thousands of aliens from their refugee camp. Watching the movie, one get’s the impression that the violence is over-dramatized to the point of a horror movie. However, the following Euronews report shows that, if anything, real life in Johannesburg is worse than the fiction of District 9:

With all this turmoil, what could possibly lead Mr. Mbeki to see any signs of renewal? Known for being “aloof” and “intellectual,” Mbeki puts his faith in his new institute TMALI which will provide a “new cadre” of skilled laborers who would in turn be “participants sharing their skills and knowledge with poor communities.”

Thabo Mbeki, President of South Africa (1999-2008)

For Mbeki, Africa has been on the path to good governance, economic growth and stability for the past two decades. He said the democratisation of most African countries, shown by regular elections, had contributed immensely towards rebuilding the continent. What was needed now was “the building of a big enough core of people” to ensure the continent stayed on this path.
~Nkululeko Ncana, Times Live

Once criticized for his “quiet diplomacy,” Mbeki is now attempting to cultivate a small number of skilled (invisible) leaders to guide South Africa toward a renewal from within. Whether deliberate or not, this approach employs a Complex Adaptive System to address chaos and change from within. It will be interesting to see if this approach to social entrepreneurship will work in the coming years. A lot is at stake.

The Chaos Journal


An unexamined life is not worth living.
~Socrates

As the purpose of this blog/project evolves, the theme of social entrepreneurship keeps recurring. That is, recognizing social problems and finding ways to fix them. Using Chaos jargon, we might say a social problem is one of randomness in the emergence process (i.e. prevents society from functioning in an orderly manner). Social entrepreneurs are usually interested in tackling the big problems head on. However, Chaos Theory has taught us that it is the first iteration – the individual – that sets the eventual climate for social development.

As a first step in this blog/project, individuals are invited to keep a journal of chaos in their lives. We’ll use the 6 Characteristics of Chaos as our guide, but there is considerable overlap and these categories are just a tool, not strict structure. Consider this an exercise in self and situational awareness; a meditation on the things you can’t control in life. The goal is to gain a sense – an intuitive knowledge – of the system that is your life. We say sense because no one will ever have enough data to totally know, let alone understand themself fully. However, you can get a sense of self, and that is more useful than statistical data anyway.

Note: There are two things we are trying to avoid in this project:
1.) Making predictions about the future
2.) Attempting to control/manipulate outcomes

Adaptivity
Adaptivity in an individual’s life can’t be discussed without taking a look at stress. PsychologyToday.com defines stress as follows:

Stress is simply a reaction to a stimulus that disturbs our physical or mental equilibrium. In other words, it’s an omnipresent part of life. A stressful event can trigger the “fight-or-flight” response, causing hormones such as adrenalin and cortisol to surge through the body. A little bit of stress is exciting—it keeps us active and alert. But chronic stress can have detrimental effects on health. You may not be able to control the stressors in your world, but you can alter your reaction to them.

Stressors are beyond our control, but if we move our focus away from control/prediction and toward adaptability we become robust to their negative impact on us.

For this section, write one event (not directly/intentionally caused by you) which caused you the most stress today. For the “bigees,” let’s use The Holmes & Rahe Stress Scale. If you go to that link, you’ll see numbers next to the event (Death of a Spouse tops the list at 100 points). Put that number next to the event. If nothing major happens (good!), still write down the most stressful thing that happened that day. Some days it’ll be a paper cut, others a car accident. (No number needed for the little stuff.)
Example: Dismissal from Job (47)

Sensitive
Most people have heard of the Butterfly Effect – idea that the tiniest initial conditions (a butterfly flapping its wings) can determine far-reaching outcomes (like a weather pattern). The same is true for a human life. Pondering the characteristics of dreams, Freud wrote that each dream…

Butterfly…has at its disposal the earliest impressions of our childhood, and brings to light details from this period of life, which, again, seem trivial to us, and which in waking life were believed to have been long since forgotten.

We are made to be sensitive to these “early impressions,” but as with stressors, the important thing is to be aware and ready for your own ignorance, because even if you were to interview everyone who knew you as a toddler, you will never get a clear enough picture. You will always be capable of more good (or evil) than you will ever know.

What are your earliest impressions from childhood? Write one or two words which are imbued with meaning from the earliest childhood/adolescence you can remember. It may be an image, smell or even a taste. It will probably have significance to no one but you. (You may want to keep your journal by your bed, where you can write as soon as you wake up.) Next to the word(s), type “+”, “-” or “~” for positive, negative or neutral meaning respectively.
Example: rose+

Deterministic
Closely related to sensitivity is determinism: the idea that the course of your life is determined by those same initial conditions. In the field of psychology, pathology is the study of mental or emotional paths which are considered either an illness or disease. If, for instance, you have trouble telling the truth, you are labeled a “pathological liar.”

Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,
And sorry I could not travel both
And be one traveler, long I stood
And looked down one as far as I could…

~Robert Frost, The Road Not Taken

Chaos Theory teaches us that we are all pathological to some degree. What are the paths that determine your personality? Share a personality trait which you consider “core” to your identity. As with everything in this journal, it should be something beyond your control. Need help coming up with a personality trait? EmotionalCompetency.com has a useful chart found here.
Example: Timid

Intractable
Chaos is difficult to both manage and predict. Life is full of unpredictable events we can learn from. Nassim Nicholas Taleb wrote a book called The Black Swan about unpredictable events (called “Black Swan” events, because these birds were so rare that people for a long time believed them to be a myth). Mr. Taleb writes that a Black Swan is an event which…

First… lies outside the realm of regular expectations, because nothing in the past can convincingly point to its possibility. Second, it carries an extreme impact. Third, in spite of its outlier status, human nature makes us concoct explanations for its occurrence after the fact, making it explainable and predictable.

He goes on to summarize these three characteristics as:

  • Rarity
  • Extreme Impact
  • Retrospective Predictability
  • Using this analysis of Nassim Taleb, write about an unforseen event you witnessed which falls under at least one of these categories: rarely happens, has an extreme impact on you (physically, mentally, or emotionally), or something which (in hindsight) you feel you “should have seen coming.” Black Swans can be positive (+) or negative (-), depending on your perspective. This means they are subjective in nature.
    Example: Inspired by poetry reading (+).

    Emergent
    Understanding how to observing and, if possible, cultivate a climate for emergence is one of the main goals of this blog. Share about a project or process you have been working on which seems to “have a life of its own.” Obviously, this doesn’t happen every day, so this might be only an occasional (but important) part of your journal.
    Example: Blog topics to write about seemed to present themself.

    Recursive
    The idea that life is recurrent is not a new one. The Wikipedia article on Eternal Return says:

    The Ouroboros, ancient symbol of autopoiesis

    The concept initially inherent in Indian philosophy was later found in ancient Egypt, and was subsequently taken up by the Pythagoreans and Stoics.

    With recurrence comes the idea of renewal - one of our themes on this blog. As discussed on the About page, we view history as fractal, not spiral (as the ancient Hebrews believed), or linear. This means, while events recur in our lives, they are never exactly the same. They are (we are) in constantly in the process of transformation.

    Write about an event, beyond your control, which has happened before. Next to the event keep a tally of times this has happened. [Eventually we will be asking for volunteers to participate in a recurrence study.]
    Example: Dream about work (2).

    Things you may notice
    - Maybe the most important thing to notice is that all of these things are beyond your control.
    - There is overlap: things we adapt to might also be recurrent.
    - The journal records situations, events, images and character traits. It does NOT record your actions or behaviors. Again, it is about the things beyond your control.

    There is now a Journal Page with occasional examples from the blog author’s Chaos Journal and place for you to leave comments on insights gained from the journal.

    [If you enjoy reading our posts, consider.... Donate towards my web hosting bill! ]

    .

    6 Characteristics of Chaos


    1. Adaptive
    2. Sensitive
    3. Deterministic
    4. Intractable
    5. Emergent
    6. Recursive

    (This list is a summary of Life With a Rock Star.)

    Life with a Rock Star


    I find it amusing that people think I’m together… because I’m the most untogether person I know. In the band, they just say, ‘Here comes chaos.’
    ~Bono, U2

    In the past few decades, Chaos Theory, along with his “backup singers” The Fractals, has become a huge rock star. He’s created cool art, starred in movies and even dabbled in the music industry (with Brian Eno, for instance). Beyond pop culture, he has applied himself in just about every area of science there is: from medical research (studies in lung disease) to computer science (the study of complex systems at the Santa Fe Institute). In fact, the only area of study scientists have had trouble applying the Chaos Theory to is… anthropology, the study of humans. Why? The short answer might be stated simply: we’re just too darn chaotic.

    You see, the name “Chaos Theory” is somewhat of a misnomer. Like all good talent agents, mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot humbly admits that he did not create Chaos & The Fractals, he simply discovered them. What he was studying at the time were cotton prices in the stock market. What he found in that chaotic data were recurring patterns. In every study Mandelbrot has done since, he has begun with chaos and ended with order. But… “The Order Theory” just wouldn’t do for a rock star. It needed a stage name: “Chaos” has appeal to a …wider demographic.

    So why doesn’t Chaos like to play with humans? To understand, we must go backstage and visit the Chaos “changing room.” It’s there we find that Chaos is actually a pretty neat fellow. In fact, we learn, the wild-and-crazy-guy bit is all an act (another misunderstood artists). Here are some of the consistent principles he abides by:

      Highly Sensitive to Initial Conditions- Does Chaos get “butterflies” in his stomach before performing? Darn right he does! If he gets a lukewarm reception on the red carpet before the show, it will affect his performance on stage. Like most primadonnas, Chaos is temperamental. He goes by first impressions, just like the old saying, “The way it begins is the way it goes.”

        Deterministic- From the very start, Chaos was destined to be a star. It was his destiny. With Chaos, those “inital conditions” we just spoke about determined everything that was to happen in Chaos’s entire life. He didn’t have a choice in the matter; his life was determined from the outset.

          Recursion- Chaos likes to say “practice like you perform.” In fact, he practices constantly. His whole life is a model of each period of his life, which is a model of each set of performances, which is a model of each gig, which is a model of each song, which is a model of each “lick” he plays, which is a model of each note within the lick, which is a model of the overtone series, which is a model of… well, you get the idea.

            Self-organizing/Emergent- It may seem contradictory, given what we just said about recursion, but Chaos is the king of improv. He may be recursive, but he doesn’t do much planning. He likes to say, “Things just work themselves out,” and he’s right! From chaotic beginnings his life has become organized and structured.

              Intractable- If you’ve seen the mockumentary “This is Spinal Tap” you know that rock stars are difficult to manage. In fact, Chaos has burned through every manager he’s ever had. This is because he’s virtually (although not entirely) unpredictable. But that’s also why he’s a great artist. So… it’s complicated, or better yet… “complex.”

              The Mandelbrot SetIt’s a little ironic to be anthropomorphizing The Chaos Theory when it has this problem with humans we keep ignoring. Well, no more! Enter randomness, Chaos’s archrival. All the beautiful designs Mendelbrot and others have made with Chaos & The Fractals assumes the absence of random elements. Something is “random” when it has no aim or purpose. The “Mandelbrot Set” (pictured left) is computer generated with no Randomness.

              Within the human life all elements of chaos are present: it’s influenced by its beginnings, it is deterministic, and it’s intractable. Into our perfectly planned lives comes Randomness. You thought Chaos was corrupting your children? Wrong! Randomness crashes “after-show” party and sends the perfectly designed Fractals in a completely different direction.

              In the next few months I will be keeping a “Chaos Journal” here on the blog which will chart Chaos and Randomness in my life. (Not that my life is of any particular interest – other than being a little more chaotic that most.) This is a first step to a larger project involving more people. In fact, you’re invited to join me and make your own Chaos Journal and post your comments.

              [If you enjoy reading our posts, consider.... Donate towards my web hosting bill! ]

    Introduction


    I am the people – the mob – the crowd – the mass.
    ~ Carl Sandburg, Chicago Poem 1916

    Characterization
    Question Defined: Can a large, diverse group of individuals acting as independent, simultaneously acting agents be used in a Complex Adaptive System (CAS) environment to produce problem solving strategies with accurate, robust and sustainable results?

    Observations: 1.) Minimum size of group needs to be defined,
                              2.) The greater the diversity the better,
                              3.) Actions of agents must take place at the same time,
                              4.) The group will be given only the problem – no other direction,
                              5.) Results will need to be tested independently for accuracy

    Hypothesis
    A “mob” of Renaissance Men/Women will exhibit characteristics of a Complex Adaptive System (CAS) and be able to solve highly complicated social problems using a collective consciousness.

    Objective
    To observe Chaos and Emergence in individuals and groups and apply the Complex Adaptive System Theory to social science with a practical outcome. This will be accomplished first by observing characteristics of these systems in an individual’s life, then testing how purposeful, simultaneous change can be used to solve social problems.